Paul McGeough on Hamas

The Sydney Morning Herald’s Middle East correspondent, Paul McGeough, is interviewed by Katia Bachko in the latest issue of Columbia Journalism Review.  McGeough is working on a book that explores Hamas’ 20-year history, and so in this interview he reflects on what it means to represent key players in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in the face of the kinds of gross simplifications that often circulate in the media, but he also looks at what Hamas is, what the organization means to Palestinians, and what it means to Israelis.  Here’s an excerpt:

To simply state that somebody is a moderate or somebody is a militant, and expect the reader to use that as the sole description or descriptor of an individual or an organization, doesn’t deliver all that could be delivered. You’re talking about Hamas? Hamas are militants, yes, they are militants who appealed to Palestinians at an election that was supervised by Western observers and deemed to be fair, and Palestinians chose the militants not necessarily because of their militancy, but because of their belief in them on a whole range of issues. And then you have to ask, “if they’re militants, if they are terrorists, how did they get to be allowed to contest an election? Who let them contest an election?” Israelis allowed them to contest the election, Americans allowed them to contest the election, Fatah allowed them to contest the election.Right up until that first election that Hamas contested in 2006, Hamas had been saying, “We represent about fifty percent of Palestinian public opinion, therefore we should be accorded that level of representation in various Palestinian forums.” And everyone laughed, and said no, that’s not true, that’s not right, and so they allowed them to contest the election. Even though they had refused to renounce violence. There’s not too many militant or nationalist or liberation groups that have been allowed to contest elections without renouncing violence. They were allowed to do so, and they won the election. That has to count for something in your assessment in where Hamas stands in Palestinian affairs, and in the region.

He also asks: what is Fatah, that Hamas could beat them in this election?  He does a good job of showing us the complexities behind easy words like “moderate” and “terrorist,” what makes Hamas as an organization that uses terror different from a terrorist organization like al-Qaeda, and how deeply hated corrupt Fatah had become by the time it was elected out of power.

–L.L. Wynn

One Response to Paul McGeough on Hamas

  1. mustafa ramadan says:

    Hamas, Israel & the West

    The emergence of Hamas was one of the Palestinians’ responses to Israeli occupation of Palestine and oppressing and humiliating the Palestinians.
    Hamas gained the trust of the Palestinians and Arabs because of its leaders’ and members’ integrity and sacrifice, and because of its social and medical services to the miserable Palestinian people.

    In one of the stages of its struggle against the Zionist occupation of Palestine, Hamas was forced to resort to suicide operations because it was the only way left to it to inflict losses on the Israelis who took Palestinians’ land forcibly and committed countless atrocities against them as all the world knows.

    The problem with the Israelis’ and the West’s logic is that they readily find excuses for the IOF violence and butcheries, but they automatically and strongly condemn Hamas’ violent reactions. The West accepts and blesses the Zionist Likud and other bloody gangs and parties, but it does not tolerate the existence of Hamas as a resistance organization, although it came to power through transparent elections overseen by the West.

    This is double standard and hypocrisy. The other fallacy practised by the Zionists and pro-Zionists is that they give themselves the right to destroy a whole nation and don’t want it to react.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: